>> Continued From the Previous Page <<
That is not a slowdown.
That is a corporate wipeout happening in slow motion.
While Subway continues closing stores year after year, competitors are moving in the opposite direction. McDonald’s, which Subway overtook in total locations back in 2002, now sits at roughly 14,000 U.S. restaurants and continues expanding aggressively.
The contrast could not be clearer.
One company is opening new doors while the other keeps locking them.
The beginning of Subway’s downward spiral traces back to one of the most damaging scandals in fast food history. In 2015, longtime spokesman Jared Fogle was arrested on horrific federal charges involving child pornography and illegal sexual conduct with minors.
For more than a decade, Fogle had become the public face of Subway’s “Eat Fresh” marketing campaign. His dramatic weight loss story was central to the company’s image and advertising strategy.
The scandal detonated that branding overnight.
Subway immediately severed ties with Fogle after the FBI raid, but the damage had already spread across the country. Consumers no longer viewed the brand the same way.
Still, industry experts say the real problem went far deeper than a single disgraced spokesman.
Subway’s business model had become bloated from years of reckless expansion. The company opened so many locations that franchise owners began competing against each other instead of outside rivals.
Stores were often placed just minutes apart, slicing into profits and crushing franchise operators who were already struggling with rising costs.
Restaurant Business editor Jonathan Maze explained the decline clearly through the words of one frustrated franchise owner who admitted: “Stores that were exceptionally strong five years ago are much weaker now.”
At the same time, the restaurant industry changed dramatically around Subway.
Chains like Chipotle and Jersey Mike’s captured customers by offering fresher ingredients, better presentation, and a more modern fast-casual dining experience. Subway’s once-powerful “Eat Fresh” slogan suddenly felt outdated as competitors delivered higher quality food and stronger customer experiences.
The company’s revenue numbers reflected the collapse.
Reports indicate franchise revenue fell more than six percent in 2025 alone, another warning sign that Subway’s problems are not isolated incidents but part of a long-running decline.
Yet despite the deteriorating numbers, private equity giant Roark Capital shocked the industry by purchasing Subway in 2024 for $9.6 billion.
The massive acquisition raised eyebrows across Wall Street and the restaurant world alike.
Why spend nearly ten billion dollars on a chain that has spent a decade shrinking?
Roark’s answer appears to be restructuring and consolidation.
The company installed new CEO Jonathan Fitzpatrick in 2025, bringing in the former Burger King executive to stabilize operations and attempt a turnaround. Fitzpatrick now faces the difficult task of stopping Subway’s collapse while expanding the brand overseas.
Subway insists the closures are intentional and part of a broader long-term strategy.
The company told the Daily Mail it is “focused on ensuring restaurants are in the right locations, with the real estate, visibility and operations that set franchisees up to succeed long-term.”
But critics see something very different unfolding.
Closing more than 8,000 locations over ten straight years does not look like strategic optimization to many observers. It looks like a company desperately trying to survive after years of overexpansion, declining quality, and mounting competition.
The painful irony is impossible to ignore.
Subway built its empire by expanding into places McDonald’s avoided. That aggressive strategy helped make Subway the largest restaurant chain in America by store count.
Now the very expansion strategy that made Subway dominant may also be the reason the empire is unraveling.
The chain that once covered America with sandwich shops is now vanishing from thousands of communities one closure at a time.
