>> Continued From the Previous Page <<
Her words hit like a warning shot. Even out of the corner office, Habba intends to remain a force inside the DOJ as she transitions to a senior advisory position.
The real blast came from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit. In a unanimous ruling, the judges said Habba’s authority as interim U.S. Attorney legally expired on July 1, 2025. Everything done after that date — indictments, directives, oversight — was beyond her lawful power. In plain English, they said she was never supposed to be in the job.
According to the Third Circuit, once her temporary term ended, the district’s judges had the final say on who would take charge until the Senate confirmed a permanent replacement. And those judges chose veteran prosecutor Desiree Leigh Grace.
The administration immediately fired Grace, pulled Habba’s stalled Senate nomination, and simply put Habba back into the job anyway. The court responded by tearing that maneuver to pieces.
With the ruling now in effect, defense teams in New Jersey’s busiest federal courthouses are preparing to pounce. Indictments issued under Habba’s watch may face legal challenges, and high profile cases from Newark to Camden could be dragged into a fog of uncertainty for months.
Prosecutors insist the system can absorb the shock. But the ruling cracks open a door the administration desperately wanted to keep closed.
It also punches a hole straight through a broader strategy Washington insiders have been watching closely: using “acting” appointments to bypass a Senate that refuses to rubber stamp controversial nominees. Similar fights are brewing in Virginia, Nevada, and other states where the administration has attempted the same kind of moves. The Third Circuit’s decision signals that the courts are ready to push back, and push back hard.
Habba, already a lightning rod thanks to her years defending President Trump in civil battles, didn’t shy away from her Jersey roots in her farewell.
“Make no mistake — you can take the girl out of New Jersey, but you cannot take New Jersey out of the girl,” she said.
As of now, the Justice Department has no replacement lined up. Officials are weighing whether to appeal the ruling, a move that could take the fight all the way to the Supreme Court. In the meantime, one of America’s largest federal prosecutor’s offices is left without a confirmed leader, and the administration is staring down yet another legal firestorm.
What happens next could reshape the power struggle over U.S. Attorney appointments nationwide — and this time, the courts seem ready to hold the line.
