“If somebody who’s a naturalized citizen — which I believe Ilhan Omar is — is convicted of a crime, that doesn’t automatically mean that they face denaturalization or anything like that,” Hansen told Fox News Digital. “They would be handled by any type of other normal punishment that would come from the court.”
In other words, prosecutors would need more than a criminal conviction to pursue the extraordinary step of revoking a person’s naturalized citizenship. The government would have to establish a separate legal basis for denaturalization.
Federal Investigation Could Have Major Implications
Hansen was appointed to the immigration bench by former Attorney General Pam Bondi and served in that position for approximately four months before returning to his legal career.
His assessment comes amid reports that federal agents searched Omar’s Washington, D.C., residence on October 12. Authorities reportedly seized her passport, cellphone, and computer as part of the investigation.
The operation was reportedly conducted by Homeland Security Investigations, the investigative division of the Department of Homeland Security. Fox News subsequently reported that investigators had also obtained Omar’s DNA.
According to reports concerning the case, authorities are examining allegations that Omar or her late father may have supplied false information during the naturalization process. Other claims circulating in connection with the investigation concern the congresswoman’s alleged original name, with sources reportedly identifying her as “Ilhan Nur Said Elmi.”
That claim has not been independently established, and the allegations under investigation should not be treated as proven wrongdoing.
The central legal question is whether investigators can produce evidence demonstrating that any alleged deception was material to Omar’s acquisition of U.S. citizenship.
If such evidence emerges, the consequences could extend beyond a potential criminal prosecution.
Hansen explained that the Department of Justice would have to initiate a separate civil proceeding to seek the revocation of naturalized citizenship.
“A denaturalization proceeding, or somebody to strip somebody of their naturalization, is another proceeding, which would be a civil proceeding brought by the Department of Justice, presumably maybe on behalf of the Department for Homeland Security, who handles most of these things,” said Hansen.
The distinction is significant. A criminal case and a denaturalization case operate under different legal procedures, and the government must satisfy the requirements applicable to each.
What Could Make Denaturalization More Likely?
According to Hansen, evidence establishing a direct relationship between a criminal offense and the naturalization process could strengthen the government’s rationale for pursuing denaturalization.
“If there was some sort of nexus between the criminal conviction and somebody’s citizenship, it might be more likely that the Department of Justice would bring a denaturalization proceeding,” Hansen continued. “But I think it would be a discretionary matter within the people who are running the Justice Department.”
That means the ultimate outcome would depend on the evidence uncovered, the applicable law, and decisions made by federal officials.
The government cannot simply revoke citizenship because a public figure is accused of wrongdoing. It must establish legally sufficient grounds through the appropriate process.
For Omar, the allegations therefore present several distinct questions: whether investigators uncover evidence of an offense, whether prosecutors determine that criminal charges are warranted, and whether the evidence supports a separate effort to revoke her naturalization.
None of those outcomes is automatic.
Nevertheless, if investigators establish that material false statements were made during the citizenship process, the legal exposure could become considerably more serious.
Could the Age of the Allegations Become an Obstacle?
The passage of time presents another potential challenge for investigators, particularly if the alleged conduct occurred many years ago.
Statutes of limitations restrict how long the government has to bring certain criminal charges. The applicable deadline depends on the specific offense, the governing federal statute, and the circumstances of the alleged conduct.
Hansen suggested that concealed fraud could raise additional questions about when those deadlines begin to run.
“My view of that is generally that fraud stops any statute of limitations. In other words, if something isn’t disclosed or something’s hidden, then it would be unfair to the other party to toll a statute of limitations against them,” said Hansen. “That’s just sort of a general principle of law.”
However, his observation should not be interpreted as a universal rule that every allegation of fraud automatically suspends every statute of limitations.
Federal law contains different rules for different offenses, and courts examine the specific circumstances when determining whether a prosecution remains legally possible. The government’s ability to pursue older allegations would therefore depend on the relevant statutes and evidence.
The question of denaturalization also has its own legal requirements, making it important to distinguish the deadlines and standards applicable to a potential criminal case from those governing a civil citizenship challenge.
Former Judge Raises Broader Concerns About Immigration Enforcement
Beyond the allegations surrounding Omar, Hansen used his experience on the immigration bench to highlight what he described as serious problems within the nation’s immigration court system.
He pointed to a substantial backlog of pending removal cases and concerns about asylum applications that may lack credible supporting evidence.
Hansen estimated that Minnesota alone had between 20,000 and 30,000 pending removal cases without scheduled court dates.
The backlog, he argued, illustrates the strain placed on a system that must evaluate large numbers of claims while determining which applicants qualify for legal protection under existing immigration law.
“Whether you want to call it fraud or whatever, it’s like an overwhelming of the system and the system is not being used in the way in which it was intended,” he explained.
Hansen also described encountering asylum applications during his time on the bench that raised substantial questions about their credibility.
He said some claims “just totally didn’t add up,” while documents submitted in support of other applications were “clearly fake.”
“There were other asylum applications that just clearly lacked merit under existing law,” he continued. “I mean, people would — I’ve seen cases where people would say, ‘Well, people insulted me in my country.’ And my response to that is, ‘Your country probably provides more protection against insults than the United States. In the United States, we have freedom of speech, and for the most part, you can be as rude as you want to someone and insult them, and it’s not a crime.’”
His remarks underscore a broader debate over the integrity of asylum claims, the resources available to immigration courts, and the government’s ability to distinguish legitimate requests for protection from applications that do not meet the legal standard.
The Investigation’s Next Steps Remain Critical
For now, the allegations involving Omar remain a matter for investigators and the courts. Reports of searches, evidence collection, and federal inquiries do not, by themselves, establish that a crime has occurred.
The most consequential development would be evidence demonstrating that any alleged misrepresentations were material to the congresswoman’s naturalization or otherwise violated applicable federal law.
Such findings could open the door to additional legal action, but the government would still have to follow the appropriate procedures and meet the relevant legal standards.
Hansen’s analysis offers a clear distinction between criminal punishment and denaturalization: one does not automatically trigger the other.
As investigators continue examining the reported allegations, the questions surrounding the evidence, the applicable statutes of limitations, and the Justice Department’s potential response will determine whether the case advances beyond the investigative stage.
Until those questions are resolved, any suggestion that Omar will be criminally charged or stripped of her citizenship remains speculative.


