For Massachusetts residents, the central issue goes beyond the governor’s private relationships.
It concerns whether the judicial selection process provides sufficient safeguards against favoritism, whether potential conflicts are properly disclosed, and whether nominees receive consistent scrutiny regardless of their political connections.
Healey’s Former Partner Receives a Nomination to Massachusetts’ Highest Court
One of the most closely examined appointments involved Gabrielle Wolohojian, a longtime Massachusetts Appeals Court judge who previously had a romantic relationship with Healey.
The two were together for years before their relationship ended in 2019.
After becoming governor, Healey nominated Wolohojian to serve on the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, the state’s highest judicial authority.
The nomination immediately raised questions about whether a governor should appoint someone with whom she had shared a significant personal relationship.
The Boston Globe’s editorial board criticized the decision, describing its appearance as “dreadful on optics”.
That criticism centered on public confidence in the judiciary rather than a finding that Wolohojian lacked the qualifications to serve.
Judicial ethics standards require judges to consider recusal when personal relationships or circumstances create reasonable questions about their impartiality.
Those concerns become particularly significant when a justice could potentially hear cases involving an administration led by a former romantic partner.
Supporters of the nomination have pointed to Wolohojian’s extensive legal experience and judicial record.
Critics, however, have argued that professional qualifications do not eliminate the need to examine potential conflicts.
The distinction matters because the public must be able to trust not only that judges act independently, but also that the process used to appoint them is transparent.
Another Judicial Pick Brings Attention to Healey’s Current Partner
The questions resurfaced in October 2025 when Healey selected Gillian Feiner for a Massachusetts Superior Court judgeship.
Feiner had spent 15 years as an assistant attorney general before joining the States United Democracy Center in 2023.
At the organization, she worked as senior counsel under Joanna Lydgate, its president and CEO.
Lydgate is also Healey’s current romantic partner.
The Boston Globe reported the professional connection between Feiner and Lydgate, bringing another dimension to the discussion surrounding the governor’s judicial appointments.
According to the account provided in the original reporting, Healey’s administration maintained that Feiner was qualified and that Lydgate “was not involved” in the selection process.
That distinction is important. A professional connection to a governor’s partner does not, by itself, demonstrate preferential treatment.
Nevertheless, the circumstances invite questions about the safeguards governing judicial nominations.
How are candidates evaluated when they have professional connections to people close to the governor?
What steps are taken to prevent personal relationships from influencing appointments?
And how much information should the public receive about those safeguards?
Those are questions that can be asked without challenging the nominees’ professional accomplishments or making assumptions about their private lives.
Healey’s Personal Relationships Have Become Part of the Public Debate
Healey and Lydgate previously worked together in the Massachusetts attorney general’s office.
The couple publicly stated that their romantic relationship began in 2020, several months after Lydgate departed the office.
Their relationship has since become part of Healey’s public profile.
But the controversy surrounding the judicial appointments is not about the governor’s sexual orientation or whether she should be entitled to privacy.
It is about how personal connections intersect with the exercise of government authority.
Governors routinely appoint former colleagues, longtime associates, and attorneys whose careers have crossed paths with their own.
Massachusetts is no exception.
The challenge is determining when those connections warrant additional disclosure, independent review, or restrictions on participation in the selection process.
Those standards should apply consistently, regardless of the governor’s party affiliation or personal circumstances.
The Boston Globe Raised Concerns About the Selection Process
The suggestion that Boston journalists entirely ignored the controversy is not supported by the available reporting.
The Boston Globe examined Wolohojian’s nomination and published an editorial questioning both the appearance of the appointment and the broader judicial selection process.
The newspaper also reported on Feiner’s professional relationship with Lydgate.
Wolohojian’s appointment attracted criticism from Massachusetts Republican leaders, who questioned the appropriateness of selecting a former romantic partner for the state’s highest court.
Healey defended her decision, emphasizing Wolohojian’s experience and qualifications.
Wolohojian had served approximately 16 years on the Appeals Court, authored hundreds of judicial decisions, and participated in thousands of cases.
The governor’s screening committee recommended her, and supporters argued that a past personal relationship should not disqualify an otherwise qualified candidate.
The Governor’s Council ultimately confirmed Wolohojian by a 6-1 vote on February 28, 2024.
That outcome demonstrated substantial institutional support for the appointment, even as questions about its appearance persisted.
Political Scandals Have Long Raised Questions About Media Standards
The controversy also fits into a much older American debate about how journalists examine politicians’ private relationships.
Former Democratic presidential candidate Gary Hart became the subject of intense national scrutiny in 1987 after reports about his relationship with Donna Rice.
The revelations severely damaged his presidential campaign and contributed to his withdrawal from the race.
Decades later, disagreements continue over how much attention journalists should devote to politicians’ personal conduct.
Conservative media critics, including NewsBusters, have argued that allegations involving Republican and Democratic politicians sometimes receive dramatically different levels of coverage.
Those comparisons can be difficult to evaluate because scandals differ in their evidence, legal implications, public relevance, and historical circumstances.
The more useful question is whether journalists apply consistent standards when a politician’s personal relationships overlap with official responsibilities.
In Healey’s case, the judicial appointments present identifiable government decisions that can be examined independently of the governor’s private conduct.
Judicial Independence Remains the Central Issue
Wolohojian’s appointment and Feiner’s nomination involve different circumstances.
One concerns a governor’s former romantic partner.
The other concerns an attorney who worked for the governor’s current partner.
Neither situation alone proves misconduct, and the available reporting does not establish that either nominee received preferential treatment.
Still, judicial appointments carry consequences that extend well beyond a governor’s term in office.
Judges may decide cases involving government agencies, constitutional disputes, criminal prosecutions, and challenges to executive authority.
That makes transparency in the appointment process especially important.
Massachusetts voters, lawmakers, and journalists have a legitimate interest in understanding how nominees are screened, how potential conflicts are addressed, and whether political or personal connections influence the process.
The issue is not whether Healey’s relationships should automatically disqualify qualified attorneys from judicial service.
It is whether the public can independently assess the fairness of the decisions.
For any governor entrusted with shaping the courts, that is a question worth answering.


