>> Continued From the Previous Page <<
“Wait. What voting rights is he taking away from black voters?” Jennings asked, forcing the panel to explain exactly how the law would harm minority voters.
Blow responded bluntly, asking, “The SAVE Act?” while Johnson quickly added, “Oh, we look at The Save Act, that’s exactly what we’re talking about. That is actually going to continue to disenfranchise overwhelmingly a lot of people of color.”
Jennings repeatedly pressed Johnson to explain how the bill would remove voting rights from lawful citizens. After several attempts, Johnson argued that voter ID requirements amounted to a poll tax, something banned under the 24th Amendment.
That explanation didn’t satisfy Jennings, who turned to polling data to make his case.
“Does it — does it concern you that you’re making all these claims, you’ve yet to lay out how it’s hurting anyone, but 76 percent of black voters think we should show an ID to vote, 80 percent of Hispanic voters, 83 percent of the American people?” Jennings asked.
He then delivered the line that ignited the panel.
“Are you saying that black voters are too dumb to know what’s good for them? I mean, it sounds pretty condescending.”
As the back-and-forth intensified, Abby Phillip, the show’s host, stepped in to redirect the conversation.
“Just to be clear, the Save Act is not just about IDs. The Save Act is about proof of citizenship. So, it doesn’t — I actually — we talked about this — I was about to say, we talked about this before. It’s not — it actually — there’s an argument to be made that red state voters, women, poor white voters could be —”
Jennings immediately jumped in.
“You think they’re dumb, too, don’t you? I mean, that’s the thing. I hear these arguments —”
Adding fuel to the fire, CNN data reporter Harry Enten had previously acknowledged strong bipartisan support for voter ID laws. During a Feb. 3 appearance on CNN News Central, Enten noted that at least 70 percent of both Black voters and Democrats support voter ID requirements.
Despite that data, Johnson doubled down, accusing Jennings of deflecting from claims of racism.
“There’s a deflection from talking about Donald Trump’s racism right there,” Johnson said.
Jennings ignored the accusation and instead reaffirmed his position.
“Yeah, I think they’re smart enough to figure out how to register to vote, Abby.”
Phillip countered by arguing that many Americans lack access to passports or birth certificates.
“Hold on, hold on. Most Americans don’t have a passport. Many Americans don’t have access to their birth certificate,” Phillip said, adding that married women who change their names often face bureaucratic hurdles.
Jennings refused to retreat, questioning whether Democrats truly believed large segments of the population were incapable of navigating basic civic responsibilities.
“Listen, this — all week long, all week long, I have heard Democrats with the same argument,” he said.
Phillip pushed back, saying, “So, Scott, why don’t you actually respond to the substance of what I’m saying, as opposed to making this about something that it’s not? It’s not just about voter ID. It’s also about who has access to —”
Jennings closed with a blunt challenge that underscored the conservative critique of Democratic rhetoric.
“You’re saying married women, black voters and rural people are too stupid to figure out how to register to vote?” he asked. “Are you saying they can’t figure out how to vote?”
The exchange highlighted a growing divide in the national conversation over election laws—one where Republicans argue for equal standards applied to everyone, while Democrats continue to frame minority voters as uniquely incapable, a narrative many conservatives say is not only false, but deeply offensive.
