Newsom’s office denies that the governor participates in the company’s operations, while PlumpJack maintains that its contractors are expected to obey applicable laws. City Journal+1
Undercover Phone Call Raises Questions About Vineyard Hiring
The most revealing episode in the investigation involved a telephone call placed to RVM by a contact working with City Journal.
Speaking Spanish, the caller identified himself as a recently arrived Mexican national seeking agricultural employment.
An employee explained that the grape harvest was nearing completion but indicated that some positions remained available.
The conversation then turned to the caller’s qualifications and immigration documents.
After discussing his experience with vineyard work and tractors, the caller acknowledged that he possessed neither a Green Card nor a Social Security number.
Rather than immediately ending the conversation, the employee requested his telephone number and indicated that a manager could contact him about employment.
That response attracted the attention of investigators.
A source familiar with undocumented agricultural employment practices interpreted the exchange as an indication that the company might be willing to hire the caller.
“That means they’re going to hire him,” the source told investigators.
However, the recorded interaction, as described by City Journal, did not establish that the caller received an actual job offer, was hired, or began working. City Journal
Former Employee Claims Undocumented Workers Dominated the Workforce
The telephone exchange was only one component of the investigation.
A former RVM employee alleged that approximately 80 percent of the company’s workers lacked lawful immigration status.
“The other 20 percent had regular status,” the former employee reportedly explained.
“We’re talking about the majority across all the work crews being in the same situation.”
Asked whether company management understood the alleged situation, the former worker responded:
“Absolutely, of course. There was a lot of them.”
Those allegations have not been independently established through a comprehensive examination of employee immigration records.
Nevertheless, they add to longstanding questions surrounding agricultural labor practices in California, where employers frequently depend on seasonal workers and outside labor contractors.
RVM manager Oscar Renteria previously acknowledged the complicated immigration circumstances facing agricultural workers.
In a 2017 discussion with the American Immigration Council, Renteria said that “many of our farm workers have what I call a complicated immigration status.”
His comments reflected the immigration challenges facing the agricultural workforce, although they did not establish that particular employees were working illegally.
Federal Employment Verification Records Add Another Question
Investigators also examined RVM’s participation in E-Verify, the federal electronic employment eligibility verification program.
According to City Journal, the contractor did not appear in the government’s publicly searchable database of participating employers.
E-Verify allows participating businesses to compare information from employment documents against federal records.
However, participation is not universally mandatory for private employers, and absence from the database does not establish that a company has violated federal immigration law.
Employers generally must still complete required employment eligibility verification procedures, including Form I-9, whether or not they participate in E-Verify.
The distinction matters because the investigation raises potential compliance questions without establishing that RVM knowingly employed unauthorized workers.
Newsom’s Financial Connection to PlumpJack Draws Scrutiny
The investigation also examined Newsom’s continuing financial relationship with PlumpJack, the hospitality and wine business he helped establish before becoming governor.
According to City Journal, Newsom retained an ownership interest through a blind trust after taking office in 2019.
The company’s vineyard holdings include the Oso Vineyard property in Napa Valley, which PlumpJack acquired in 2022.
RVM has reportedly handled vineyard operations for the business since at least 2023.
The arrangement has prompted questions about whether Newsom’s financial interests intersect with the immigration policies pursued by his administration.
However, ownership through a blind trust does not, by itself, establish that Newsom directs hiring decisions or knows the immigration status of employees working for an outside contractor.
His spokesman, Izzy Gardon, told investigators that Newsom “placed his business interests in a blind trust when he took office in 2019” and “has no involvement in PlumpJack’s operations or management.”
PlumpJack separately said it expects “all vendors working with [it] to comply with the law.”
RVM did not respond to the publication’s requests for comment. christopherrufo.com
Newsom’s Immigration Policies Become Part of the Debate
The findings arrive amid continuing disagreements over California’s spending on services available to undocumented immigrants.
Newsom’s administration has supported healthcare access and legal assistance programs for certain immigrant populations.
Critics question the financial sustainability of those programs and argue that California’s policies can indirectly benefit industries that rely heavily on immigrant labor.
Supporters maintain that healthcare access, workplace protections, and legal representation serve broader public interests, including protecting vulnerable workers from exploitation.
The City Journal investigation connected those policy debates to Napa Valley’s agricultural economy.
However, statewide expenditures on immigrant services cannot automatically be characterized as subsidies to Newsom’s vineyards. Establishing such a financial relationship would require evidence tracing specific expenditures to identifiable business benefits.
Newsom’s 2025 Veto Adds Another Layer to the Controversy
The report also revisited Newsom’s decision to reject Assembly Bill 1136 in October 2025.
The legislation would have provided certain employment protections to workers dealing with immigration proceedings, including limited unpaid leave and reinstatement rights under specified circumstances.
Newsom vetoed the measure after it passed the legislature.
In his official veto message, the governor argued that its reinstatement provisions were impractical for many employers and that enforcement would impose significant additional costs on California’s Labor Commissioner.
He also directed state agencies to continue protecting workers against labor and civil rights violations regardless of immigration status.
The bill was not principally an employer-verification measure, and its veto did not eliminate existing federal requirements governing employment authorization.
Nevertheless, the decision has become part of the broader debate over how California balances immigration enforcement, worker protections, and the needs of agricultural employers. Digital Democracy+1
Previous Labor Violations Put Contractor’s Record Under the Microscope
RVM’s employment history presents additional concerns.
According to the investigation, federal labor authorities previously identified wage-and-hour violations involving 45 employees.
The report also described workplace safety violations and allegations from a former worker concerning overtime compensation.
These matters are distinct from the question of immigration authorization.
Still, they underscore why oversight of agricultural labor contractors remains important.
Workers who fear losing their employment or facing immigration consequences may be reluctant to report mistreatment, potentially making labor-law enforcement more difficult.
The documented labor violations warrant examination on their own merits, regardless of the affected employees’ immigration status.
Questions Remain for Newsom and His Vineyard Contractor
The investigation has not established that Gavin Newsom personally authorized unlawful hiring, directed RVM’s employment practices, or knowingly benefited from specific immigration violations.
It has, however, raised questions that could be answered through additional documentation and investigation.
Did RVM consistently complete required employment verification paperwork? What did management know about the immigration status of its workforce? Were PlumpJack’s contractor compliance expectations independently audited?
And what procedures does PlumpJack use to ensure that agricultural contractors working on its properties comply with federal employment and state labor laws?
For Newsom, the controversy illustrates the potential tension between public policy responsibilities and private financial interests.
For RVM, the immediate questions concern hiring practices, employee protections, and compliance with existing law.
The undercover call alone does not prove illegal employment. Combined with the former employee’s allegations and the contractor’s documented labor history, however, it provides grounds for further scrutiny.
Whether that scrutiny produces evidence of immigration-law violations remains an open question.


