The decision not to pursue charges centers on a critical distinction under Kansas law: prosecutors must establish more than an isolated act of carelessness to bring certain criminal vehicular manslaughter charges.
In this case, Bennett concluded that investigators could not establish that the woman knowingly or recklessly created the deadly danger.
The district attorney’s report described the incident as an act of “negligence,” explaining that the available evidence did not demonstrate criminal intent or the conscious disregard of a substantial risk.
“The reasonable conclusion is that, while she slept, her foot unintentionally hit the gas pedal while the truck was in gear,” the report stated.
However, investigators acknowledged that they could not definitively establish why the vehicle remained in drive when the woman stopped at the sports complex. One possibility raised in the report was that she simply failed to shift the truck into park after arriving.
Investigators also examined whether drugs, alcohol, or mechanical problems contributed to the tragedy. Neither explanation was supported by the evidence.
There was no indication that the driver was impaired by substances, and investigators found no mechanical malfunction that would explain the truck’s movement.
Prosecutors Say Evidence Falls Short of Criminal Charges
Bennett addressed the difficult decision publicly, acknowledging the magnitude of the tragedy while explaining why his office could not proceed with criminal prosecution.
According to USA Today, the district attorney emphasized that his responsibility was to follow the evidence and apply the law, regardless of the emotional weight surrounding the case.
“It is my solemn responsibility to stand before the community and say, as bad as this was, it is not a crime,” Bennett said.
He explained that prosecutors could not establish the mental state required to demonstrate criminal recklessness.
“I cannot prove she consciously disregarded a tremendous risk that took people on that field. And finally, I cannot prove she did anything more than a single act of negligence which according to the Kansas Supreme Court is insufficient to charge vehicular manslaughter,” he said.
The distinction is significant. While the circumstances resulted in two deaths, criminal prosecution requires evidence satisfying specific legal standards. Prosecutors cannot simply substitute the severity of an outcome for proof of the elements of a crime.
Bennett further explained that investigators found no evidence suggesting the driver understood the truck had remained in drive or that she knowingly exposed others to danger by falling asleep.
“In other words, she would have to have known the truck was in drive (or would be placed in drive) and further recognized that by falling asleep, she risked inadvertently pressing the gas pedal and killing and hurting people,” Bennett wrote.
“There is no evidence to support such conclusions.”
That determination does not necessarily mean the woman will escape all legal consequences.
Bennett indicated that the families could pursue the matter through civil litigation, where the burden and standards of proof differ from those required in a criminal courtroom.
“This is a civil matter that will be handled under a negligence standard, which is the standard in civil cases,” the DA said, according to ABC News.
DA Defends Decision: ‘Why Wouldn’t I?’
The decision has undoubtedly placed Bennett in a difficult position, particularly given the loss of two lives and the understandable desire for accountability.
Speaking about the decision, he made clear that declining prosecution was not a matter of personal preference.
“If I could charge somebody, why wouldn’t I?” Bennett said, according to the Associated Press. “But I also have an obligation to stand up and say, ‘It’s not here.’”
His comments underscore the legal limitations prosecutors face when the evidence does not establish the elements necessary to support criminal charges.
Wichita Police Chief Joe Sullivan also defended the investigation, saying officers pursued the available leads and carefully examined the evidence before reaching their conclusions.
“Every lead was examined. Every piece of evidence was reviewed. Every reasonable avenue available to us was pursued… Our responsibility is not to fill gaps with assumptions or speculation,” Sullivan said.
Police Recreated the Incident Using an Identical Truck
One particularly important part of the investigation involved determining whether the pickup truck could have moved forward on its own without the driver pressing the accelerator.
To examine that possibility, Wichita police conducted a reconstruction using an identical truck.
Investigators positioned the vehicle under similar circumstances and monitored whether it would move without anyone touching the accelerator.
According to Bennett, the test showed that the truck remained stationary, even after an extended period.
The vehicle was positioned with its tires against a curb measuring approximately seven inches in height.
“We sat there and waited and waited,” Bennett said. “After about 15 minutes we went, ‘This truck isn’t moving.’ … Tires against a 7-inch curb and it did not move.”
The experiment supported investigators’ conclusion that the accelerator had to be pressed for the vehicle to move forward under the conditions tested.
Authorities believe the sleeping driver’s foot unintentionally engaged the accelerator, causing the truck to advance toward the soccer field.
Bennett also described the woman’s emotional condition immediately after the collision.
When emergency responders pulled her from the vehicle, she was reportedly devastated by what had happened.
The district attorney said the driver was “sobbing, at turns described as frantic, hysterical, saying, ‘I’m sorry, I’m sorry. What have I done?’”
Her reaction became another detail in an investigation that ultimately found no sufficient basis for criminal prosecution.
For the families of Cole Adrian and Nicholas Schafer, however, the legal conclusion does nothing to reverse the devastating consequences of that day.
A young child and an adult lost their lives during what should have been an ordinary day of youth soccer. The investigation may have answered important questions about how the truck moved, but the loss suffered by those families remains immeasurable.
With criminal charges off the table, any further legal accountability will likely have to be pursued through the civil justice system.


